New album is ‘out’ and we can read first reviews. Expressen’s journalist and old time Roxette reviewer Anders Nunstedt writes his review, gives 2/5 to the new album and sais that “Roxette’s comeback album is a clear return to the successful sound. Just a bit more boring. Without the former charm.”
He adds that “album is not bad, is rather twice as good as “Room Service”.” and concludes with note that “”Charm School” is a typical middle-of-the-road pop-up to 70 km/h, with no specific destination. Stable, but not adventurous. But then it sounded fun.”
There’s also two Czech reviews, both very possitive. See the links below:
Swedish
Expressen 2/5
Corren 4/5
UNT.SE (no rating)
Dagens Nyheter 3/5
Göteborgs Posten 2/5
SVD 1/6
Kristianstadsbladet 2/5
Västerbottens-Kuriren 2/5
Kulturbloggen 3/5
Aftonbladet 2/5
Musikindustrin (positive, putting critics into context)
Australian
The AU Review 6/10
Rave Magazine 3/5
Czech
t-music (no rating)
Rock & Pop 4/5
German
Plattentests 5/10
aerodynamite.tv 3/5
butjer 4.5/5
news.de (no rating)
Focus 8/10
laut.de 3/5
n-tv (no rating, but very positive)
cnet.de 6/10
monsters & critics (rating: “convincing”)
CD Starts 6/10
Greek
Music Bug 9/10
Italian
Debaser 3/5
Accordo.it (no rating)
Norwegian
varden.no 4/6
oslopuls 2/6
Venezuelan
El Tiempo (no rating)
If you find any “Charm School” review somewhere on the internet, don’t hesitate to post a link to the discussion under this article!
DN gives points from 0 to 5, 5 being the highest.
http://www.sydsvenskan.se/kultur-och-nojen/article1379876/De-goda-tiderna-ar-forbi.html
Another poor review 2/5. It’s strange but most of the review don’t talk about music. The emphasis is on the glorious past, Gyllene Tider, but with almost zero mention to music itself. Anyway i was expecting better reviews from swedish media, this time at least.
Metro gives Charm School 1/5 with the comment: “”Roxettes comeback album is like a unpleasent surprise in the back of the refridgerator”.
http://www.metro.se/se/misc/pdf/2011-02-09/SERIK_2011-02-09.pdf (Page 18)
Rather nice review by Kulturbloggen. They actually listened to the album several times and focus on the music. 😛
I agree with you. Kulturbloggen has reviewed the album. The rest of the swedish media seems to have reviewed Roxette. Also it feels like they all compare CS with the old albums instead of making a review of CS.
yes, typical envy dissing Gessle reviews. And Nundstedt speaks and the rest follow. Pathetic!!! Instead of being proud of such a great band which, they like it or not, made history and will always be related to Sweden, nooooo let’s be negative, let’s hate them for being THAT successful.
But well, I have seen that before with Eva Dahlgren.
Allehanda sais that is not a flop, it’s a chance for Marie to sing again. 2/5 http://allehanda.se/noje/skivor/1.2735627-troget-men-mediokert
Dalarnas tidning. 2/5 http://www.dt.se/noje/skivor/article891029.ece
Smålandsposten: “A Roxetteversion of Mazarin”. 2/5 http://www.smp.se/noje_o_kultur/skivor/veckans-skivrecensioner-20110209%282274067%29.gm
I feel sorry for swedish media, it’s clear they’re biased… of course, music is not objective, but giving CS 1 point, that’s really embarassing, at least for me 😉 I’d be happier if swedish people were proud of them 🙂
A good review here, although it’s not a professional one, I think 😉
http://www.reviewstream.com/reviews/?p=141602
http://www.varden.no/kultur/roxette-er-tilbake-etter-dramatisk-avbrudd-1.6020865
The first review from Norway – 4/6.
http://oslopuls.aftenposten.no/musikk/article499274.ece
Another review from Norway – 2/6.
Aftonbladet – 2/5
http://www.aftonbladet.se/nojesbladet/musik/recensioner/article8548701.ab
A short but favourable review: Germany – FOCUS online – 8/10. http://www.focus.de/kultur/musik/plattenkiste/tid-21281/platte-der-woche-roxette-pj-harvey-bright-eyes-mogwai_aid_598462.html
RAVE MAGAZINE, Australia: ***
http://www.ravemagazine.com.au/content/view/25166/180/
THE AU REVIEW, Australia: 6/10
http://www.theaureview.com/albums/roxette-charm-school-2011-lp
Nice review from Germany: http://www.laut.de/Roxette/Charm-School-(Album)
3 stars is great for a pop record at that site. 🙂
New reviews from Norway;
http://www.vg.no/musikk/artikkel.php?artid=10029919 (VG – 2/6)
http://www.dagbladet.no/2011/02/15/kultur/musikk/musikkanmeldelser/anmeldelser/roxette/15447677/ (Dagbladet 2/6)
http://www.t-a.no/kultur/anmeldelser/musikk/article151476.ece (Trønderavisa – 4/6)
one more swedish review
GAFFA – 3/6 http://gaffa.se/recension/46687
German n-tv.de:
http://www.n-tv.de/leute/musikundfilm/Roxette-melden-sich-charmant-zurueck-article2607156.html
“Charm School is […] a typical Roxette album, which currently makes it an outstanding longplayer.”
“None of the bands [which have recently released a comeback album] – maybe except OMD – has got such an unmistakable, unique sound like Roxette. And that’s exactly what makes them so special – even ten years after their last studio.”
http://www.facebook.com/notes.php?id=119185021432790¬es_tab=app_2347471856#!/note.php?note_id=195613760456582